The myriad definitions show nations struggling to define terrorism in selfserving ways. Moreover, governments have been reluctant to formulate an agreedupon and legally binding definition. Library of congress federal research division the sociology and psychology of terrorism 2 essentially anyone who is not a fundamentalist muslim or an aum shinrikyo member. Jul 18, 20 one of the most striking aspects of the study of terrorism is that there is actually no commonly agreed definition of what terrorism is. Most universally accepted definition there is no universally agreed on definition of terrorism. However, without a universally accepted definition, a framework for global cooperation against terrorism has been established. The international community has not formed an agreed and binding definition of terrorism to the world. This book first explores the policy reasons for defining and criminalizing terrorism, before proposing the basic elements of an international definition. Return to article details terrorism in the eye of the beholder. In what may seem as a challenge to common terrorism studies thought, boaz ganor, israels leading scholar of terrorism studies, proposed a short and concise definition that highlights counterterrorism practice and prioritizes the safeguarding of civilians. It is a fact that a single, commonly accepted or applied definition of. The term terrorism means premeditated, politically motivated violence perpetrated against noncombatant targets by subnational groups or clandestine agents.
Firstly, terrorists didactic intention or didactic value. A politicized and poorly conceived notion crying out for. Thus, the determination of the rightdefinition of terrorism is subjective and not likely to be reached by. I had given my prior agreement to the home secretary. Terrorism is an essentially contested concept, there will probably never be a universally agreed upon definition of the term.
The failure to craft an agreed definition of terrorism has left a vacuum for actors, whether. Headway has been made, ben saul confirms, but an ultimately successful definition will have to walk a fine line. Their outlook is one that divides the world simplistically into them and us. Pdf terrorism is characterized not only by its manifold nature and complexity but also by the problem with its definition. The term terrorism is profoundly political, as can be seen by the numerous definitions of terrorism and the lack of a globally agreed description. Finally, this gtd codebook supersedes prior codebooks. This chapter develops further the theme introduced in chapter 1 of the importance of conceptualizing terrorism, both in the policymaking and academic environments.
No universal definition of terrorism can thus be discerned from them. Scope the joint publication jp 102, department of defense dictionary of military and associated terms, sets forth standard us military and associated terminology to encompass the joint activity of the armed forces of the united states. Bruce hoffman of georgetown university has defined terrorism as violenceor equally important, the threat of violenceused and directed in pursuit of, or in service of, a political aim. It is both subjective and pejorative by its very nature, something universally accepted amongst terrorism scholars. Has the united nations agreed yet on a single definition of what.
At best, we have a most universally accepted definition of terrorism, which is the following. Consensus stumbles particularly on issues of legitimacy, assessing reasons behind the violence and whether a state can commit acts of terrorism or whether they are to be excluded as they have the monopoly on legitimate violence. In such scenarios, the user can filter the data according to specific components of established definitions of terrorism. Agreement on definitions of terrorism will assist the. Pdf the history of terrorism, most likely originated from the history of political violence yet the term terrorism is comparatively recent. The intelligence community is guided by the definition of terrorism contained in title 22 of the us code, section 2656fd.
In the united states of america, terrorism is defined in. The obligations established by the international treaties against terrorism the principal obligation set forth in the international treaties against terrorism is to incorporate the crimes defined in the treaty in question into the domestic criminal law, and to make them punishable by sentences that reflect the gravity of. The manner, in which the terrorist attack was launched, had shaken the entire world in general and united states of america in particular. Dealing with terrorism has become the centerpiece of u. Adopted by the european council in 2005, this strategy commits the union to combating terrorism globally, while respecting human rights and allowing its citizens to live in an area of freedom, security and justice. Army manual definition terrorism is the calculated use of unlawful violence or threat of unlawful. In an effort to assist teachers in helping their students identify and understand terrorism, the united states institute of. A good place to start is with the definition alex schmid proposed in the volume he edited with albert jongman, political terrorism. This module is a resource for lecturers defining terrorism before examining the meaning and associated concepts and principles of international criminal justice and international criminal law as they apply to terrorist crimes, it is first necessary to briefly examine some of the principal reasons for, and implications of, the absence of a universally agreed definition of terrorism, including. Terrorism should be defined and criminalized because it seriously undermines fundamental.
The terrorist attack on world trade center and pentagon has given a new dimension to terrorism. So a variety of both academic and national definitions will be analysed to highlight the recurring elements in the hundreds of definitions that have been established. It is therefore a justifiable characteristic of my chosen definition. No agreed definition of terrorism, or how to define or measure any key metric. In formulating an effective counterterrorist strategy, the construction of a universal definition of terrorism. Terrorism according to chomsky terrorism can be defined as the calculated use of violence or the threat of violence to attain political or religious ideological goals through. It is estimated that since 2004, terrorism has cost the eu about 185 billion in lost gdp and around 5. The different legal systems and government draw divergent definitions of terrorism. Most universally accepted definition there is no universally agreedon definition of terrorism. In particular, it illustrates how terrorism has continued to be used as a subjective label and stresses the need for a more analytical approach in determining what terrorism is. United nations counterterrorism implementation task force. Despite numerous efforts since the 1920s, the international community has failed to define or criminalize terrorism in international law. Importance of an agreed definition of terrorism oxford. Comprehensive convention on international terrorism which would include a definition of terrorism if adopted and a convention for the suppression of acts of nuclear terrorism.
Politics, by its nature, is adversarial, and thus any definition evokes adversarial disagreement. Reaching an agreed definition of terrorism has proved problematic, with over 100 different working definitions counted. An overview of the political theories of terrorism. The definition of terrorism has found to be controversial. While a definition of terrorism, like a definition of war is not solving the underlying problem, a lack of definition is perceived widely as one of the factors likely to encourage future terrorism. The challenge of defining terrorism establishing a universally accepted definition of terrorism remains a work in progress. Oau convention on the prevention and combating of terrorism en oau convention on the prevention and combating of terrorism fr oau convention on the prevention and combating of terrorism po status list en treaty category tags. Marcs definition of terrorism contains 4 elements 1 first, terrorism is at root a violent act a. Central intelligence agency cia definition of terrorism. Abstract of research paper on terrorism definition and types today, terrorism is one of the major threats, being faced by most of the world states. In the absence of an internationally agreed comprehensive definition of terrorism, where states link counter terrorism measures to a definition of terrorism or acts. This convention can address the weaknesses of the current regime, create a sustainable mechanism through which state parties can assess the effectiveness of nuclear security governance and implementation, and allow for continuous improvements. The difficulty in defining terrorism is in agreeing on a basis for determining when the.
Definition of terrorism social and political effects journal of. These military and associated terms, together with their. Although the term is not subject to a universally agreed definition, terrorism can be. Various legal systems and government agencies use different definitions. The revised academic consensus definition of terrorism. Many scholars have come up with their own definitions of the term but it has been impossible to reach a consensus to define terrorism internationally. Difficulties arise from the fact that the term has become politically and emotionally charged.
The unlawful use of force or violence against persons or property to intimidate or coerce a government, the civilian population, or any segment thereof, in furtherance of political or social objectives. But lack of agreement on a definition does not mean. Various definitions of terrorism controversy in defining terrorism the difficulty in defining terrorism is in agreeing on a basis for determining when the use of violence directed at whom, by whom, for what ends is legitimate. Human rights, terrorism and counterterrorism ohchr. The general assembly despite many years of debate, the general assembly has thus far been unable to agree on a definition of terrorism. All counter terrorism measures must comply with the principle of legality. Most researchers tend to believe that an objective and internationally accepted definition of terrorism can never be agreed upon. Due to terrorism s political and emotional overtones, governments have hesitated to develop an agreed upon definition that can be used to tie terrorist acts to specific laws.
Typically, they are at average or overaverage levels in terms of. Any attempt here at a definition of semiotics is at best preliminary and partial. Unfortunately, absence of an agreeable definition is a major obstacle to meaningful international counter measures. Definitions of terrorism wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. International treaties against terrorism and the use of. These difficulties came up, as the word terrorism, relates to emotions of public at.
There was broad agreement that there is only a weak and indirect relationship between poverty and terrorism. Some questions about the definition of terrorism and the. The chapter argues that all terrorism related theories are contingent upon, or should be contingent upon, what one means by terrorism in the first place. Notwithstanding the absence of a globally agreed, legal definition of terrorism, an effective and preventionfocused international response to terrorism is highly desirable, particularly one guided by a normative legal framework and embedded in the core principles of the rule of law, due process and respect for human rights. In the absence of a legal definition, attempts have been made since the 1980s to reach agreement on an academic consensus definition. Following the watershed attacks of 911, governments have found themselves confronted, not only with a need to implement protective policies against attacks, but also respond to the, often inflated and mediapropelled, collective will and fear of the population. Although the term is not subject to a universally agreed definition, terrorism can be broadly understood as a method of coercion that utilizes or threatens to utilize violence in order to spread fear and thereby attain political or ideological goals. Reliance on media sources or unstated sources, cancelation of nctc and all official u. It is used in this regard primarily to refer to violence during peacetime or in context of war against noncombatants mostly civilians and neutral military personnel. The ad hoc committee on terrorism of the 6 th legal committee of the general assembly has, with some interruptions, been trying to reach a legal definition since 1972 but in vain.
With its sarin attack on the tokyo subway system on march 20, 1995, the. It is for this reason that a comparison is necessary to clarify the scope ofthe operation of the terrorism risk insurance programmes. Feb 09, 2014 it is therefore a justifiable characteristic of my chosen definition. Similarly, louise richardson of oxford university believes terrorism. The matter of definition and conceptualization is usually a purely theoretical issuea mechanism for scholars to work out the appropriate set of parameters for the research they intend to undertake. But lack of agreement on a definition does not mean that the international community has made no progress in combating the. Agreeing on the basics american diplomacy est 1996. There have been some definitional differences in the use of the terms terrorism and act of terrorism between oecd countries. Fundamental characteristics even if the meaning of terrorism has changed over time, some of the fundamental conceptualizations of terrorism have remained remarkably consistent or constant over the decades. A substantial number of international conventions have been agreed which deal with various aspects of terrorism, but in all these conventions terrorism is defined in a way that is specific to the subject.
Dean and yonah alexander have placed the absence of a definition on the first place of a list often such factors table 3. There is no universal agreement on the definition of terrorism. In the united states, however, various government agencies have developed definitions of terrorism and domestic or homegrown terrorism. However, without a universally accepted definition, a framework for global cooperation against terrorism has been established gradually since 1963 in numerous.
Terrorism is, in the broadest sense, the use of intentional violence, generally against civilians, for political purposes. Therefore, the eu has developed a holistic counter terrorism response the eu counter terrorism strategy pdf. At the individual level, terrorists are generally not drawn from the poorest segments of their societies. Nonprofits and grantmakers need to know a plainlanguage guide to executive order 224, the patriot act, embargoes and sanctions, irs rules, treasury department voluntary guidelines, and usaid requirements. The first reason, then, for persisting with the definition of terrorism, or at least an agreed conceptualization of the term, is that the term has more than ever before been open to abuse.
In the absence of a universally agreed upon legal definition of terrorism and extremism, and an obligation to take all necessary measures to combat them, states may be tempted to craft their own overly broad definitions that can be exploited for. Consensus stumbles particularly on issues of legitimacy, assessing reasons behind the violence and whether a state can commit acts. Oau convention on the prevention and combating of terrorism. It will, in other words, have to reconcile political expediency with international law.
Defining terrorism, then, sets the parameters for terrorism research, not least in informing the. The imperative quest for a universally agreed definition of terrorism download download pdf download download pdf. The question of who is a terrorist, according to this school of thought, depends entirely on the subjective outlook of the definer. But lack of agreement on a definition does not mean that the international community has made no progress in combating the problem. While member states have agreed on many provisions of the draft. Pdf an overview of the political theories of terrorism. Army manual definition terrorism is the calculated use of unlawful. The meaning given to terrorism is part of a persons or nations philosophy. Terrorism is the use of force or violence against persons or property in violation of the criminal laws of the united states for purposes of intimidation, coercion, or ransom. Moreover, governments have been reluctant to formulate an agreed upon and legally binding definition. The united nations in the fight against terrorism javier. Some questions about the definition of terrorism and the fight. Try to convince citizens that their government is powerless to prevent terrorism.
Yet terrorism, its definition, causes, and methods of dealing with it, has rarely been dealt with in high school courses. If a domestic definition of terrorism, agreed upon and shaped by the government cannot control the government in its actions, there is little hope for the quest for an international definition of terrorism that seeks to control and bind the various disparate perspectives on terrorists and freedom fighters in international law. A new guide to actors, authors, concepts, data bases, theories and literature. Terminology consensus would be necessary for a single comprehensive convention on terrorism, which some countries favor in place of the present 12 piecemeal. Terrorism remains a contested term, with no set definition for the concept or broad agreement among academic experts on its usage. That is the use of violence to educate or to rally the masses.
1526 1511 257 946 488 513 781 1073 591 16 197 523 1332 259 1149 812 1278 16 242 1382 870 1371 1316 275 571 254 944 1351 696 1044 541 216 1008 115 1211